| Doctor Who Topic | |
|
|
Favorite version? | First Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Second Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Third Doctor | | 17% | [ 1 ] | Fourth Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Fifth Doctor | | 17% | [ 1 ] | Sixth Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Seventh Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Eighth Doctor | | 0% | [ 0 ] | Ninth Doctor | | 17% | [ 1 ] | Tenth Doctor | | 33% | [ 2 ] | Eleventh Doctor | | 16% | [ 1 ] |
| Total Votes : 6 | | |
|
Author | Message |
---|
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Doctor Who Topic Thu Jul 26, 2012 6:31 pm | |
| Yes, here it is. The topic all about the series. Any aspect of Doctor Who can be discussed here (pretty much anyway), so if you have something to say, discuss away! And yes, I do watch it as well. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Fri Jul 27, 2012 2:55 pm | |
| Yeah, this seems like the sort of thing you'd be into.
My aunt insisted upon introducing me to one of the students she met while volunteering at her daughter's high school. I found it odd that she'd try to arrange a meeting between her nephew and a teenager she wasn't really connected with, but naturally we hit it off. As well as discussing Minecraft and Dungeons and Dragons, he convinced me to check out Doctor Who. I asked him when I should start and he said the "Fifth Season", which I misunderstood as the "Fifth Doctor" - which is why the only vote cast is from me, for the only Doctor I actually know.
I think the Fifth Season is somewhere around the Ninth Doctor, so I'm pretty far behind, and haven't been watching too many episodes as of late. I used to watch a part a day, but I hit an episode I didn't care for ("Soldiers of the Deep" or something) and I haven't watched anything since.
I've considered skipping the episode and keeping on moving forward with the Fifth Doctor, or perhaps skipping ahead to the Ninth Doctor and the "New Who" series.
Your thoughts?
Last edited by The Spectral Mask on Tue Aug 07, 2012 2:10 pm; edited 1 time in total | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:22 pm | |
| Heh... Anyway, the fifth season is actually (as far as I know) the first one featuring the Eleventh Doctor, so it's way ahead. You have the option of moving ahead with the Fifth Doctor up through the Eighth Doctor before you get to the new series, of course, but you're going to hit the discontinuity between the Eighth and Ninth Doctors if you do that. Personally, if you continue with the series, I'd recommend starting with the first season of the Ninth Doctor. The new series really is a continuous(ish) timeline, so if you do jump into the "New Who" then start with the Ninth Doctor. (His first episode is called "Rose" if that helps you any.) I'll refrain from going on about the new series until you've seen some of it. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:39 pm | |
| Okay, I'll check out the Ninth Doctor at some point, then.
And then I suppose I'll have you and my neice's peer to chat about it with. I've been watching episodes on Life, Doctor Who, and Combom, even though I'm not certain what Combom means. Does the "New Who" retain the four-part structure? | |
|
| |
Lord Mayhem First Toa Team
Posts : 1735
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Fri Jul 27, 2012 9:57 pm | |
| one of my favorite series of all time started with the 9th doctor and on the 11th now I havent watched the older ones but I really reccomend the new who because it is really awesome | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sat Jul 28, 2012 5:38 pm | |
| @Spectra(l), I guess you're asking if there's four parts to each episode, or rather four episodes to each story? If so, nope. Quite a lot of episodes are one-time things, although I'd say maybe up to half the episodes are two-parters (and season enders tend to be three-parters). @Iraemancer, it is awesome. Do you have any favorite episodes or arcs? -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| |
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sat Jul 28, 2012 7:45 pm | |
| No, don't bother watching the Eighth Doctor's movie. He only got the one special, and there's no television episodes that explain his regeneration into the Ninth Doctor, so... Next, I don't always mind shorter episodes, but they could potentially be an excuse for sloppiness. I wasn't sure why the Doctor wanted her along either, but hey, he needs a companion I guess. And last, the Time War is a major plot device throughout the new series... but to literally paraphrase someone involved in the new Doctor Who, "Even when the Master does die, he can't die." (I won't spoil much, but the two new incarnations of the Master are pretty well-played.) -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sat Jul 28, 2012 9:10 pm | |
| The Eighth Doctor only had one movie, huh? ... that's weird. I guess the show was already on the way out.
The whole companion thing can get pretty forced at times. I've only seen about four of them during the Fifth Doctor's Era, but of the four I liked Turlough the best. While both he and his Guardian were over-the-top actors, Turlough's motivation made perfect sense until his story arc was resolved. After that, he decided to stay to "learn more", which lumps him back in with the rest.
I won't pry into the details about the Time War, but I can't see the Master dying in defense of the Time Lord Council, so I guess he could survive. The only thing is, I don't understand how Regenerating works without the Time Lord's technology - I thought that was what allowed it to happen, rather than some aspect of their specie’s nature. I even assumed that the twelve-time cap was artificial, because "The Five Doctors" contained a scene where the Master is offered a new set of regenerations.
I'm glad to hear he's still kicking, all the same. Ainley's Master was pretty hammy, but although his plans were complex I always loved them. Sometimes, I even rooted for him, and that's terrible. | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sat Jul 28, 2012 10:56 pm | |
| Yeah... The TV series of Doctor Who had already been canceled by the time the Eighth Doctor came along (at least the Seventh Doctor appeared at the beginning of that movie before the regeneration, and that kept the continuity), so I doubt there were ever plans to continue the adventures of the Eighth Doctor on television. I've never found the new companions' recruitment too forced, but I guess I am a bit surprised they stay with the Doctor despite the monsters and such. They have no strong reason to remain other than ridiculous fascination. Yeah, the Master definitely wouldn't bother dying to save the Time Lords or anything. I'm not sure how regeneration works either, because Time Lords have to generate quite a lot of energy to regenerate, but all three* times I've seen proper** regeneration happen in the new series, it's happened in the Tardis (TARDIS?), so it could be that that helps. Also, the twelve-regeneration cap has been discarded now. The old versions of the Master (the Third Master? I can never remember what number of Master we're on) were kind of likeable, yes. Not so much the new Master(s), but they're better villains that way, I guess. * - Spoiler:
Subtle spoiler there. I won't explain that yet...
** - Spoiler:
Disregard River Song, acquire Time Lords.
-|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Lord Mayhem First Toa Team
Posts : 1735
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sun Jul 29, 2012 1:48 pm | |
| @wally my favorite would have to be the sound of drums
@spectral haha I ALWAYS root for the villain master and yeah I love how complicated all his plans were | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sun Jul 29, 2012 3:14 pm | |
| I suppose I would join the Doctor's crew, for no better reason than fascination. I've got a feeling in my gut that the new companions are going to join and leave with a little more prominance, while in the older series they'd come and go mid-season with little fanfare.
I expect to see Rose until the end of season one at least.
No more Twelve-Regeneration Cap? The Master's worked around it at least once, maybe on a few other occassions ... I figured it had something to do with the Time Lord's Core on their home planet I can't spell, so if they were destroyed in this Time War I don't see how everything keeps going.
One episode featured some people who had equiptment to replicate Time Lord Regeration ... I'll see if I can find it ...
I look forward to seeing the New Master, guys!
Oh, and I didn't click either spoiler. I already know too much of what's to come this season at is is. XD | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Sun Jul 29, 2012 5:40 pm | |
| Yeah... I'd almost certainly take over join the club too. And yes, the new companions only really leave due to catastrophes and stuff like that. Rose was/is no exception. I never really understood the twelve-regeneration cap anyway, so I see no reason for the story team not to ignore it now. Last, my first spoiler wasn't much of a spoiler. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 2:48 am | |
| Out of curiosity, who voted for what (other than Spectral for the Fifth Doctor) and why?
-|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Lord Mayhem First Toa Team
Posts : 1735
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 4:01 am | |
| I voted for the elventh although the ninth and tenth was pretty awesome as well I havent had too much experience with the first 8 (or any at all) so i cant really say anything about them | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 2:22 pm | |
| Wow ... while Umbra and I were on vacation, we watched almost all of season one. I was suprised to see the Ninth Doctor go so fast. Having seen most of the Fifth and now all of the Ninth, I'm confident that the Fifth Doctor is my favorite so far. The Fifth Doctor was sporty, friendly, and to-the-point. He seemed to be on a level playing field with his companions (never saw him with less than two). If a given companion was the team's chemist, the team's mathmatician, the team's coordinator, the Fifth Doctor was simply the pilot, and they all got along swimingly.
The Ninth Doctor got on my nerves - he did have an excuse for his often belittling attitude, haunted by the death that seemed to follow him - but I hope that the Tenth Doctor discovers his own way of interacting with the other characters, his own personality.
Any reason IRL why Chris Eccleston left the show so quickly? | |
|
| |
Cryomancer The Cold Mage
Posts : 5869
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 10:05 pm | |
| I voted the 3rd Doctor because he looks great. | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 10:13 pm | |
| @Irae, okay then. @Spectral, I was not only surprised (sort of - I'd had a bit of the first season spoiled for me ) but disappointed/displeased that the Ninth Doctor was gone so quickly. He had a lot of potential for growth - more than I thought (at first) the Tenth Doctor had. It's kind of ridiculous that the Ninth didn't get that kind of chance. I really don't know why Eccleston left the show at all. It was originally reported that he was certain on staying for a second season, but there was this suspicious business of the BBC reporting that he was leaving before he decided to. It kind of seems that that may have caused his departure. @AF, wait, you've never SEEN the SHOW? Seriously, watch some. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Lord Mayhem First Toa Team
Posts : 1735
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 10:44 pm | |
| I should probbably watch the older episodes | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Tue Aug 07, 2012 11:14 pm | |
| ... yes, you probably should. And I should watch more of them too. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 09, 2012 12:23 am | |
| @ Iraemancer & Wally: You might consider watching "The Keeper of Traken" (Fourth Doctor). That's where I started in the old season, and I thought the story was pretty continuous from that point on. The set up is simply that the Fourth Doctor took in Adric, a young but brilliant mathmatician from E-Space, an alternate universe. Adric wants to see the Time Lord's home world, but it doesn't go as planned. Naturally.
And Arty has seen exactly one episode, "The Christmas Invasion" (Tenth Doctor). | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 09, 2012 12:34 am | |
| Okay, I'll see if I can get it. I've considered starting from the very beginning with the First Doctor's first episode, but a lot of the early episodes are still missing apparently, so that might be useless. And good for him... BUT WATCH SOME MORE, AF. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
The Spectral Mask Head Librarian & Game Master
Posts : 3659
| |
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Fri Aug 10, 2012 2:30 am | |
| Thanks for the link, I'll try it out when I'm somewhere with better internet (or when I have more time). I don't think I'll download them, but I should be able to load them okay... -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Scarey Bear The Before-Time
Posts : 6
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 6:02 am | |
| I think that if I'd started with nine, I would have liked him a lot more. Instead, I started with the eleventh Doctor, loved his personality, then went back and watched "Rose" and was not impressed. He was still great, of course (you have to be great to play the Doctor) and I warmed up to him more as the season went on. He just wasn't my favorite...
I'm also one of those people who hasn't seen the old Who, and I'm worried that if I do, it will be like watching Star Trek: The Original Series after some TNG. Anyone else know what I mean? | |
|
| |
X Comrade
Posts : 1304
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 1:13 pm | |
| Disclaimer: I have only seen approximately six episodes of Doctor Who, two of which I didn't realize were Doctor Who at the time.
That said, I started out with Ten, then jumped over (probably) several episodes to Eleven, thanks to WPT and spotty television reception. Now, I've gone back and started the series from "The Christmas Invasion". So far, Ten is my favourite, but I'm withholding judgment until I've seen more of Eleven.
@Scarey Bear: I know exactly what you mean. That's precisely the reason I been willing to see the original Who--yet. I'm sure it will be good and all, but I guess I'm just worried it'll ruin the new Who for me.
By the way, welcome to Codrex Magna! :3
---]=>TKG<=[--- | |
|
| |
Scarey Bear The Before-Time
Posts : 6
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 5:09 pm | |
| Thanks, Knife Girl. And I think that Ten is probably my favorite as well. | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 5:29 pm | |
| @Scarey Bear, reversely, I think if I'd started with the Eleventh Doctor, I think I might've liked him a bit more. I haven't seen all of his episodes of course, but even though I think he's a very good Doctor, the scripts feel kind of weak so far. It's impossible for me to have watched "The Waters of Mars" and "The End of Time" without finding "The Eleventh Hour" to be a bit of a letdown. Even the leadup to the Pandorica arc (which I haven't even finished, sign) is less well-woven-in than the Bad Wolf appearances, in that it's more of a specific blow-to-the-head name-dropping than important background noise. The Tenth Doctor is really the defining incarnation of the recent three (Nine, Ten, Eleven), but the most unusual of those three is certainly the Ninth Doctor. By now I suspect the Eleventh is pretty popular, but my favorite is still the Ninth, partly because I started with him and partly because he's so different. @Stargazer, I highly and biasedly recommend starting all the way back from "Rose" onwards. Having seen "The Empty Child"/"The Doctor Dances" makes one scene in "The Poison Sky" that much more meaningful. -|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Scarey Bear The Before-Time
Posts : 6
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 8:22 pm | |
| @Auxier, yes, "The End of Time" pretty much blew my face off. That and "Journey's End". And "Blink" and "The Shakespeare Code" (my two favorite episodes). Spoiler beneath is okay to read if you have seen all the New Who eps up through the Eleventh Doctor's first few episodes (Ep. 1 - around Ep. 5, to be slightly exact but not really) - Spoiler:
The one other thing that saddens me about the Eleventh Doctor is that he basically starts over again. With the Nine-Ten transition, he kept Rose, and visited Jack later, and his companions from both regenerations seemed to get along in the end. With Ten - Eleven, he gets a new Screwdriver, new TARDIS, and new companions, and pretty much ditches all of his old friends. I'm really hoping for the return of someone other than River Song.
| |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 8:28 pm | |
| I read the spoiler because I've watched up to episode... Eight, I think? And the first thing I have to say is RIVER. SONG. That's all I have to say about her. My favorite episode of all (so far) was, oddly enough, "The Waters of Mars". Anyway, - Spoiler:
I think it was very much the Tenth Doctor's intention to make the Eleventh Doctor start over again. The way that he talked about regenerating with Wilf made it clear that it was very much a death for the Tenth, and that he would not just grin and bear it like the Ninth. So if the Tenth couldn't see his companions again, then neither would the Eleventh. Maybe.
-|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Scarey Bear The Before-Time
Posts : 6
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:05 pm | |
| Umm... scared now... I take it you dislike her? - Spoiler:
But still, did the other Doctors make such a big deal out of their regenerations?!? He did Nine - Ten so easily ("same man, new face"), then with this one he was like "I have to make my final goodbyes" and "I have to die" and "I don't want to go!" and I'm just like COME ON DUDE. *pant, pant*
So yes. | |
|
| |
Lignar Mysterious Figure
Posts : 8336
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:13 pm | |
| Just a little. - Spoiler:
I don't actually know. The First Doctor just collapsed because he lived so long in the same incarnation, the Second Doctor had a regeneration forced on him... the Fifth Doctor had a rather prolonged death, I think, but only the Tenth Doctor truly dragged out his end by an unbelievable amount.
It was all part of the Tenth Doctor's personality, I think, though. He was extremely stubborn about that kind of thing.
-|W|G|- | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Doctor Who Topic | |
| |
|
| |
| Doctor Who Topic | |
|